Amateur Radio Operator BSA uniform patch discontinued

Discussion in 'Amateur Radio News' started by KD4MAX, Oct 10, 2018.

ad: L-HROutlet
ad: l-rl
ad: Left-2
ad: MessiPaoloni-1
ad: Subscribe
ad: l-assoc
ad: L-MFJ
ad: Left-3
  1. KD4MAX

    KD4MAX Subscriber QRZ Page


    https://k2bsa.net/2018/10/amateur-radio-operator-rating-strip-discontinued/


    Amateur Radio Operator Rating Strip — Discontinued
    The BSA's National Awards, Insignia, and Uniforms Committee has advised us that the Amateur Radio Operator Rating Strip has been discontinued. Here's the message from John Duncan, Volunteer Chair:

    The BSA recognizes that our uniform remains an important method in our program delivery. It follows that we must be good stewards of the limited space available on the uniform. It is wonderful that there are so many organizations, certifications, ratings, and professional credentials that are so well aligned with Scouting's core values, as evidenced by a high volume and continuing flow of similar requests for uniform pieces to identify current military, military veterans, civil servants, doctors and other medical professionals, EMTs, firefighters, law enforcement, clergy/faith leaders, environmental professionals, and others. The view of the committee is that while all such professions, certifications and ratings are laudable, the BSA uniform is not a proper way to recognize any of these. Instead, guidance in response to such proposals is generally what the ARRL has already done -- creation of a national-level Award for Service to Scouting, approved for inclusion as part of the community organization knot.

    While this is disappointing news, we can take consolation that we had a good run with the rating strip. Moreover, the existing rating strips can continue to be worn on the uniform. Here's the information shared by the Awards, Insignia, and Uniforms Committee:

    All discontinued Boy Scouts of America uniforms and insignia may be worn in keeping with the applicable uniform and insignia guidelines as of the time of their production, so long as condition of original insignia does not detract from the neatness of the uniform. Exact reproductions or “private issue” insignia are not authorized for uniform wear. Furthermore, existing supply will continue to be sold until exhausted, so for the passionate followers, consider buying a lifetime supply now! Although the diagrams errantly created and communicated broadly via Bryan on Scouting never made it into a Guide to Awards and Insignia, existing awards may continue to be worn as depicted in those diagrams, in keeping with this guidance.

    Given this information, it's probably time to stock up on the patches from BSA Supply. It's order number 617431 and here's the link for online ordering https://www.scoutshop.org/amateur-radio-operator-rating-strip-emblem-617431.html

    The details for uniform placement and requirements can be found at https://k2bsa.net/operator-rating/
     
    KK6JKC likes this.
  2. KD4MAX

    KD4MAX Subscriber QRZ Page

    I give these out to scouts and scouters who earn their ham radio licenses, with the next one likely to be in November. I just bought a bunch (more than I intended) so I will be issuing these for years to come.
     
    W5JGW, K1GDI, KW4WL and 5 others like this.
  3. NW9F

    NW9F Premium Subscriber QRZ Page

    That is disappointing, but the BSA has become increasingly disappointing to me over the past decade.
     
    KB2QQM, NY7Q, KD5INM and 52 others like this.
  4. KM4KGN

    KM4KGN Ham Member QRZ Page

    [QUOTE="KD4MAX, post: 4827537, member: 798279"

    The BSA recognizes that our uniform remains an important method in our program delivery. [/QUOTE]

    I haven't actually seen a Scout in uniform in many years. Most scouts this day and time, only wear the shirt with a pair of bluejeans, and 9 times out of 10 the shirt is not even tucked in. IF it is such an important part of the program...perhaps they should worry more about seeing that it is properly worn, rather than a little strip on the shoulder.
     
    NY7Q, W5JGW, N8ZL and 14 others like this.
  5. KD4MAX

    KD4MAX Subscriber QRZ Page

    Our troop is a 100% uniform troop, with random inspections counting toward inter-patrol competitions. I tell scouts to tuck in their shirts all the time. It's rare to see a scout in jeans (though I did see one at our meeting this week) but we do have to police the green socks. We only get about 70-80% compliance on that one.
     
    N9OU, NY7Q, N3VMM and 6 others like this.
  6. KD4MAX

    KD4MAX Subscriber QRZ Page

    The alternative is to let down our children and our neighbors' children. I prefer to work from the inside.
     
    N9OU, KD5INM, WA0TDA and 2 others like this.
  7. AA0RI

    AA0RI Platinum Subscriber Platinum Subscriber QRZ Page

    Several years ago, I believe it was about 1994 our Amateur radio club in Manhattan, KS was asked to come to Kansas State University and put on radio merit badge training for certification one Saturday. There were various other merit badge sessions going on at the same time at various locations on the campus.

    None of the boys that came to our radio sessions had read the book that was assigned reading prior to the session. Most paid no attention to our program and they all expected to receive the merit badge upon completion. Our club never returned to the event again when asked, we gave our reasons to the Scout officials.

    If this is what the merit badges stand for, why have them?

    Chuck Carter, AA0RI
     
    NY7Q, WK0P, KA2FIR and 5 others like this.
  8. KM4AHP

    KM4AHP Premium Subscriber QRZ Page

    That is the Radio Merit Badge Patch. That has not been discontinued and has to be earned when a scout completes all of the requirements for that merit badge which then is signed off by the merit badge counselor for that badge. The strip they are talking about is this one.
    617431.jpg
     
    NY7Q, AE4LH, NA3P and 5 others like this.
  9. W8JBM

    W8JBM Ham Member QRZ Page

    Perhaps the patch has simply gone the way of the word BOY in Boy Scouts of America. It will always be hard to watch traditions and customs die out, with some having both intended and unintended consequences. Good luck to you guys doing your best fighting the good fight!
     
    KB2QQM, AC0OB, WW3JR and 10 others like this.
  10. KB4QAA

    KB4QAA XML Subscriber QRZ Page

    There were no Amateur Radio Operator strips when I was in scouting in the 70's. BSA has always had continually evolving uniforms. I don't see this is a big deal.
     
    NY7Q, KT4RK, KE8KMF and 3 others like this.

Share This Page