ARRL FILES REGULATION-BY-BANDWIDTH PETITION

N5RFX · Dec 20, 2005

[b said:

Quote[/b] (AG4YO @ Dec. 18 2005,13:08)]

[b said:

Quote[/b] (n5rfx @ Dec. 18 2005,02:04)]Charlie,

Thanks or the explanation, it helps me to understand the tests that you wanted in the previous post. I am curious, was your digital experience, CDMA and TDMA?

The nice thing about the ARS is that the protocols are constantly changing and protocols that don't meet the challenge are dropped pretty quickly. That is the nice thing about being able to experiment, which we are able to do very liberally today. I am not as familiar with the digital voice protocols used in the ARS. We are living in the mixed environment today, what problems have occurred in this mixed environment in the ARS? I am not aware of any complaints to the FCC, nor have I read any comments or warnings from the FCC about the mixed environment that we have today. I am interested in hearing what the complaints are that are generating the concern over mixing analog and digital, when in fact we are mixing analog and digital today in the phone/image subbands right now. I keep hearing about region 1 calling for the separation of digital and analog signals, but I have not been able to find any papers discussing why the IARU feels this way. Since they did not change their bandplan for 2006 to prohibit mixing of analog and digital signals, there may be more to the story.

Thanks again for sharing your experience Charley.

73,

Mark N5RFX
Click to expand...

I tested CDMA, TDMA, and GSM. Each has it's own reasons why Analog should be segregated.
Click to expand...

Charlie,

Great experience. Are the test results public, or are they proprietary?

73,

Mark N5RFX

AD4MG · Dec 20, 2005

NC5S, why do you insist on posting a BPL announcement in a Bandwidth Petition thread? You have problems with reading comprehension and/or understanding what you read?

There is no shame here OM, if you need help, just ask.

Unless of course this is your style of trolling. Any message you may be tryng to deliver is lost in the irrelevance of posting in the wrong thread.

With that said, I wish you the best for the holiday season, and if I may so brazen in this PC correct world, Merry Christmas!

Best 73,
Luke

KY5U · Dec 21, 2005

[b said:

Quote[/b] ]Charlie,

Great experience. Are the test results public, or are they proprietary?

73,

Mark N5RFX
Click to expand...

Mark,

They are not public. If they were, I would have published them already. Believe me that when I see the Amateur digital proponents argue the SAME tripe I heard from cellular vendors 15 years ago it is amazing.

ARRL FILES REGULATION-BY-BANDWIDTH PETITION

N5RFX Ham Member QRZ Page

AD4MG Banned QRZ Page

KY5U Ham Member QRZ Page

Share This Page