Discussion in 'Survey Center' started by WW4LS, Dec 4, 2017.
All my rigs are budget transceivers. They're paid for.
and now it's "just as correct" as it was before - just different
MFJ Cubs, I have a few and the kit form cost me $ 99 each ! And they WORK .
I have made many good contacts when I take them on camping trips !
I can't imagine soemone would think a radio costing over 500 bucks would be any bargain !
My activities in ham radio are handicapped in many ways, such as antennas, location favorable to DX, etc. Since the beginning in 1970 I decided that equipment would not be another handicap and have always had the best equipment I could stretch to afford.
Having voted for the FT-891, I am surprised to see the leader by a wide margin comes with a price tag nearly twice that of the FT-891.
Is the Icom 7300 a better radio? Maybe. It depends on what matters to you.
Is it worth twice the price when price is a chief consideration (as the poll suggests)? Absolutely not.
Unfortunately we have quite a mix here. I myself prefer "portable" rigs. Something I can take with me. I don't consider a 16 lb radio portable so I would not vote for it....even though it may be a fine transceiver. As a result I voted for the FT891. A lot of bang for the buck and portable! And it's getting to be that time of the year to return to some portable operation!
The FT-891 is definitely a great portable rig.
The criticisms that I have seen all have to do with things like where in the menu system certain settings are located. I have never heard a criticism like, 'The receiver just is not as good as X radio.'
Both Yaesu's newer 'budget' offerings (FT-891 and FT991A) and the Icom 7100 use triple-conversion super-heterodyne receivers, and have DSP IF. The Icom 7300 is direct conversion. With current firmware, I think the DSP noise removal is better on the Yaesus than on either Icom. And the contour filter is incredible.
It does not seem that too many people have ever used this radio. Maybe the low price and small size leads people to think it is junk and write it off.
Have both the Yaesu FT-450D which serves as my 6-meter station and the FT-891 which is my dedicated digital transceiver. Both have been very reliable and meet the requirements of their intended use. As to an economical all-around transceiver would tend to go with the FT-450D as it has some more features.
The lack of a tuner is what I am most aware of as to differences. What else is there?