Hints and Hacks (QST)

Discussion in 'General Announcements' started by KK5R, Apr 15, 2018.

ad: L-HROutlet
ad: l-rl
ad: Subscribe
ad: abrind-2
ad: Left-2
ad: L-MFJ
ad: Left-3
  1. KF5LJW

    KF5LJW Ham Member QRZ Page


    Me thinks you got that dead wrong.

    1. Never seen an operator without kinked and coiled up cables.
    2. Every ham operator I have met has a mental and/or physical ailments. Look around and see all the Walkers, Inhalers, O2 and Geritol bottles at a club therapy meetings.
    3. Most are clever.
    4. Every ham shack I have seen is cramped, messy, and short on space.
    5. Of course all hams have imperfections and difficulty operating silly.
    6. Hams have unconventional sexual taste and behavior. If they were not spending all that time playing radio would have more time for conventional sex.
     
    KV6O likes this.
  2. KA2K

    KA2K XML Subscriber QRZ Page

    A hack could be used to describe someone that has no clue what they are doing. Sort of a bull in a china shop scenario. You would not want a "hack" working for you. So hack as an adjective is not a compliment. Hack as a verb (maybe) not such a bad thing. Two different ways of looking at it. With all of the words available, hack would not have been my first choice. Good Day. :)
     
    N2SUB and KK5R like this.
  3. KK5R

    KK5R Ham Member QRZ Page

    Very well said. Whether it as an adjective describing a hacking activity or using it as a verb, there are definitive, negative connotations. Where there is a questionable "hint" ascribed to a word, much better to just avoid the word or idea and go with the general, long-time accepted term.

    If anyone said that I had hacked something or that it was a hack job, I'd not feel it something to to be proud of. Reminds me of something my father said when I was young: "Never do anything that you can't brag about."

    Again, I cannot imagine anyone being offended by "Hints and Kinks" or that there should be anyone that sees that there is a change/improvement needed with the old term. Again, also, where a change does not provide an enhancement or betterment of a long-time traditional term, why change it?

    If it's merely a change for the sake of "changing something" — then will we see QST Magazine changed to something else? Like maybe QRZ Magazine or QRT Magazine? This is pure imagination, of course. Any fool could see that a name change does not necessarily lead to improvement even it it is to remove some imaginary negative attribute.

    Also reminds me of asking a kid if you call a cow's tail a leg, does it mean the cow now has five legs? When the kid says "Yes!" then tell him that merely calling the tail a leg does not make it a leg, it still has four legs. (This is good to teach children that just because someone says something is this or that way does not make it so...)
     
  4. K8MHZ

    K8MHZ Ham Member QRZ Page

    In the skilled trades the term 'hack' is definitely derogatory. You don't want to be called a hack, or be accused of doing hack work, or hacking up a job in any way shape or form.

    I have actually seen people be proud of work someone skilled in the trades would consider hack work. Like using all kinds of crazy things for electrical conduit.
     
    KK5R likes this.
  5. N2SUB

    N2SUB Premium Subscriber QRZ Page

    When I first noticed the name change, it did give me pause. In the vernacular of the IT world, a "hack" is a cheap, quick, and dirty fix to keep something running until you can "do it the right way". A hack is a change done out of necessity and is not intended to be a permanent fix. That's just my definition, but the word "hack" has had a negative connotation in the IT community since well before hackers were a concern.

    Well done voicing your concerns to the ARRL instead of just complaining about it on the Zed, as so many of your critics do. Unfortunately, you did not get a response. I have had the same experience. It seems these days that the fellas in Newington don't really care how the membership feels on any given issue, and that's a shame. 3 years ago I emailed HQ about an experience I had with them at a hamfest, and received a phone call within a few hours. This year, I have written to all section managers and HQ about matters that directly affect the organization and it's future, and never got a response. So, after 25 years I'm letting my membership lapse. Don't take it personally, it SOP these days for them to ignore any hint of criticism.
     
    KK5R likes this.
  6. KK5R

    KK5R Ham Member QRZ Page


    I had QST and several other ham-related magazines in the '70's and let them lapse except for 73 Mazine because I liked 73's build-it articles. It was getting too expensive. QST was more into the organization and contests/club activities. It wasn't worth it to get one or two issues a year dedicated to antennas, etc. As for the equipment reviews, some are of passing interest but most are not.

    I also liked Ham Radio and CQ but 73 was better because of the number of experimenter articles. Had some articles published in 73, too.

    When it comes to renewing and getting QST, I will have to make a decision at the proper time. It boils down to what I actually get out of QST compared to the expense. At one time, a lifetime membership in the ARRL was on the order of a couple hundred dollars but it's much more than that now. I do not have money to throw up in the air.
     
  7. N2SUB

    N2SUB Premium Subscriber QRZ Page

    And the dollar-to-years left on the planet ratio gets higher every day as well. ;)
     
    KK5R likes this.
  8. N2SUB

    N2SUB Premium Subscriber QRZ Page

    Now THIS guy looks proud to be a hack

    [​IMG]
     
    KK5R likes this.
  9. KV6O

    KV6O Ham Member QRZ Page

    I disagree. It can be, but I wouldn't say "definitely. Hack's at MIT, CalTech, UC Bizerkly, etc., can be the stuff of legends.

    This derogatory form of the noun "hack" derives from the everyday English sense "to cut or shape by or as if by crude or ruthless strokes" [Merriam-Webster] and is even used among users of the positive sense of "hacker" who produces "cool" or "neat" hacks. In other words, to "hack" at an original creation, as if with an axe, is to force-fit it into being usable for a task not intended by the original creator, and a "hacker" would be someone who does this habitually. (The original creator and the hacker may be the same person.) This usage is common in both programming, engineering and building. In programming, hacking in this sense appears to be tolerated and seen as a necessary compromise in many situations. Some argue that it should not be, due to this negative meaning; others argue that some kludges can, for all their ugliness and imperfection, still have "hack value".

    In a very universal sense, hacker also means someone who makes things work beyond perceived limits in a clever way in general, without necessarily referring to computers, especially at MIT.[24]That is, people who apply the creative attitude of software hackers in fields other than computing. This includes even activities that predate computer hacking, for example reality hackers or urban spelunkers (exploring undocumented or unauthorized areas in buildings). One specific example is clever pranks[25] traditionally perpetrated by MIT students, with the perpetrator being called hacker. For example, when MIT students surreptitiously put a fake police car atop the dome on MIT's Building 10,[26] that was a hack in this sense, and the students involved were therefore hackers. Another type of hacker is now called a reality hacker. More recent examples of usage for almost any type of playful cleverness are wetware hackers ("hack your brain"), media hackersand "hack your reputation". In a similar vein, a "hack" may refer to a math hack, that is, a clever solution to a mathematical problem. The GNU General Public License has been described as[by whom?] a copyright hack because it cleverly uses the copyright laws for a purpose the lawmakers did not foresee. All of these uses now also have spread beyond MIT as well.


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_culture. Ham radio is mentioned: "According to the Jargon File,[8] the word hacker was used in a similar sense among radio amateurs in the 1950s, predating the software hacking community."

    https://lifehacker.com/ - Full of little life "hacks".

    I guess it's all proof that words can been different things to different people. When I went to high school, being a "geek" was definitely a negative. Now it's cool. :p
     
  10. KK5R

    KK5R Ham Member QRZ Page

    Some definitions are no more than inventions from those who want to appear less then ignorant...

    Proper definitions are definitions accepted by dictionary consensus.

    There are those who invent definitions that are no more than fiction. Reminds me of a homeless guy who pushes one shopping care and pulls another. What is he? According to some who love to invent terms and scenarios, that homeless guy is a Social Climber.
     

Share This Page