Are you saying that anyone who is NOT a Tech should not have an opinion about this? Good luck with that argument. The jury won't buy it. You have gone through the process and earned your license. You are still a Tech for your own reasons. Strip out the expired licenses and the clubs and 50.235% of active licenses are Tech's. So we need more incentive to attract brand new hams, most of which have no clue yet what it means to only have very limited HF privileges. This is when we can't get 50% of the current service to upgrade, who actually do have some idea what they don't have. I have serious doubts about this plan. Unless we are shooting for 60% of all current licenses to be Techs. If that is the plan, it just might work.