ad: MyWorld-1

Marshall Island and Amelia Earhart's SOS transmissions-sending again

Discussion in 'Amateur Radio News' started by K1YTG, Dec 10, 2016.

ad: L-HROutlet
ad: l-rl
ad: Subscribe
  1. WR2E

    WR2E Ham Member QRZ Page

    Agreed that it certainly does "appear to be". But it could also be something else... Don't know what, but the pic is old, out of focus, etc.
     
  2. K4KWH

    K4KWH Ham Member QRZ Page

    I found that out last night via the local news. I was going by the story recently that first posted the theory that she landed in the Marshalls. I had not yet been advised of it. SO IS it is, is it ain't? We still don't know. As of 1937, it was still 4 years until Pearl Harbor.
    How much hostility was there between the US and Japan in '37? The materials embargo didn't take place until 40-41. So why would Japan accuse Amelia/Fred of spying given the trip was (I figure) well-publicized? Since much of their trip was over water, how much "spying" could they do? ' Woulda made more sense, IF they landed in the Marshalls, to give 'em fuel and send 'em on their way.
    Were the Japanese so "touchy" that they were shot down as an unidentified aircraft? Or DID they, as originally theorized, ditch in the sea after missing Howland Island and running out of fuel? We STILL don't know.:confused:
     
  3. K4KWH

    K4KWH Ham Member QRZ Page

    The source of the photo was reported to be the Japanese. It is still possible for the info to be bogus. What if the Japanese DO have something to hide? What if they DID 'disappear' Amelia and Fred, and now just don't want to risk criticism, even at this late date?
    Somebody somewhere *may* know what happened to them.
     
  4. N3YUG

    N3YUG XML Subscriber QRZ Page


    Did you watch the show, several of the items you ask about were addressed. They didn't land on the island they thought they were landing on, more like crash landed, we already had tensions with Japan, and the USS Panay was bombed by Japan during it evacuating American citizens from Nanjing, killing three in late 1937. I am not saying the show was all fact, but very interesting and possible. Check out the show, you will get most of the questions you mentioned answered, in some form.
     
  5. N4AAB

    N4AAB XML Subscriber QRZ Page

    I found the show to be interesting. They did their research, even if some don't agreev with the results.

    The USS Panay was sunk by the Japanese military, who later claimed they didn't know it was American. The photos taken back then show a large US flag. ThePanay had 2 machine guns. Not much armament, but the old river patrol boats weren't well armed.
     
  6. W2MYA

    W2MYA Ham Member QRZ Page

    Dr Chip:Hw have bn om? Well it's unfortunate that this experiment didn't gel.Perhaps if it was better funded by
    say the Smithsonian Institute or National Geographic with some proper guidance and greater funding
    something could have been determined as to their being lost and MIA. Perhaps some day we will all
    know.
    Respectfully, Gregory L.Mitchell-W2MYA
     

Share This Page